7 Best Walmart Eyeliners in 2022 (Don‘t Miss These Picks)

Eyeliner is one of those makeup products that can make or break your look. Choosing the right formula and shade to complement your eye shape and makeup style is key to achieving flawless eyes.

Luckily, Walmart offers an extensive selection of top-rated eyeliners at affordable prices from major makeup brands. Whether you‘re looking for a subtle enhancement or bold dramatic wings, Walmart has an eyeliner for you.

To help you find your perfect liner, I‘ve put together this guide to the 7 best Walmart eyeliners to add to your makeup bag in 2022. As an eyeliner expert with over 10 years of experience testing products and advising clients, I‘ll share my insider knowledge on choosing and applying eyeliner so you can achieve stunning eyes.

Types of Eyeliners

Before diving into the top product picks, let‘s overview the main categories of eyeliners so you can determine which formula will work best for you:

• Liquid eyeliner: The gold standard for precise, crisp lines. The fine felt tip allows you to draw thin or thick lines and perfect cat eyes. However, liquid liner requires a steady hand and practice to apply.

• Pencil eyeliner: Available in both retractable and wooden pencil options. Pencils glide on smoothly and are very beginner-friendly. Use short, soft strokes to line eyes or smudge for a smoky effect.

• Gel eyeliner: Delivers rich color payoff in a creamy formula. Usually applied with an angled brush for intense pigment. Great for smokey eyes but can be challenging for inexperienced users.

• Kohl eyeliner: Softer, more smudgeable formula. Traditionally used to line the inner rims but can also be applied to top and bottom lashlines. Creates a sultry, defined effect.

• Cream eyeliner: Typically comes in a pot and is applied with a brush. Has a matte finish that doesn‘t budge. Ideal for intense color or graphic liner looks.

How to Choose the Best Eyeliner for You

With so many formulas available, how do you choose the right eyeliner? Here are a few key factors to consider:

• Eye shape: Liquid liners and thin pencils work best for small or hooded eyes. Avoid overpowering your eyes with thick kohl or gel formulas. For deep-set or protruding eyes, bold pencil or gel liners balance proportions.

• Liner look: If you loveDramatic cat eyes and wings? Go for a liquid liner with a flexible felt tip. Prefer soft definition? Choose a kohl pencil. For smudgy, sultry eyes, cream and gel liners create impact.

• Color preference: Black is the standard, but shades like brown, navy, purple, and gray create subtle definition. Colored liners (blue, green, etc.) make a fun statement. Match eyeliner to your eye color to make them pop.

• Sensitivities: Pencil and liquid liners labeled “hypoallergenic” and “oil-free” are less likely to irritate sensitive eyes. Avoid formulas with fragrance.

Eyeliner Application Tips & Techniques

It takes practice to master lining your eyes smoothly. Here are some of my pro tips:

• Rest your elbow on a steady surface and hold the eyeliner lightly like a pencil for better control
• Look down into a mirror and lift your eyelid gently with your other hand to access the lashline
• Draw short strokes as close to the base of lashes as possible, connecting the dashes
• Allow gel/cream liners to set for 30 seconds before opening eyes to avoid smudges
• Apply eyeshadow primer before pencil eyeliner to increase staying power
• Finish with setting spray or translucent powder to lock liner in place all day

Now that you know how to apply eyeliner flawlessly, let’s get into the top liners available at Walmart this year. Based on quality, reviews, value, and performance, these are my picks for the best Walmart eyeliners of 2022 in both pencil and liquid formulas:

1. NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Sticks

Key Features:

• Ultra-creamy pencil formula
• 28 vibrant, highly pigmented shades
• Twist-up mechanical design, no sharpening needed
• Waterproof, transfer-proof, smudge-proof
• Up to 24 hours of wear

My Review: NYX Epic Wear pencils go on smoothly without tugging or skipping. The richly pigmented colors make lining the eyes effortless for beginners and pros alike. While the formula is soft and creamy, it sets quickly and wears like iron without fading or smudging. For maximum staying power, let the liner set for 30 seconds after applying before opening eyes.

Best For: All levels of makeup users. The wide shade range and glide-on texture make these liners universally flattering.

Price: $7.97

2. Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup-Proof Retractable Eyeliner

Key Features:

• Retractable twist-up mechanical pencil
• Breakup-proof, smear-resistant, waterproof formula
• Self-sharpening tip
• 3 versatile neutral shades: black, brown, navy
• Up to 16 hours of wear

My Review: This budget-friendly liner competes with prestige brands at a fraction of the cost. The mechanical design makes application quick and easy. The angled tip effortlessly defines eyes with skip-free intense color. While not as creamy as pricier liners, the lasting power more than makes up for it.

Best For: Getting sharp precise lines without needing a separate sharpener. The no-budge formula also makes these ideal for eyeliner newbies.

Price: $1.98

3. Maybelline Eyestudio Hyper Easy Liquid Eyeliner

Key Features:

• Liquid liner with flexible tapered brush tip
• Skip-free application
• Smudge-resistant, 12+ hour wear
• Intense matte black pigment
• Beginner-friendly formula

My Review: This liquid liner makes drawing the perfect cat eye amazingly easy. The tapered tip bends slightly to glide smoothly across the lashline without tugging or catching. The ink flows evenly and dries quickly. While not waterproof, the formula does resist smudging remarkably well for a budget liquid liner.

Best For: Effortlessly achieving smooth, crisp winged liner looks. The tapered applicator allows you to create both thin precise lines and thicker bold definition.

Price: $6.98

4. L‘Oreal Paris Lineur Intense Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner

Key Features:

• Innovative flexible felt tip
• Intense matte finish
• Smudge-resistant, 8-hour wear
• Ophthalmologist tested, suitable for sensitive eyes & contact lens wearers
• Deep black pigment

My Review: This easy-glide liquid liner delivers strikingly bold eyes. The flexible tip hugs the lashline, allowing you to create sharp edges and points. The ultra-black hue stays true without fading or running. While not waterproof, the transfer-resistance stands up admirably well to moisture and humidity. The smooth liquid formula works for eyeliner newbies too.

Best For: Creating perfectly crisp wings and bold dramatic liner looks that last all day. The intense matte finish is stunning for nighttime.

Price: $8.47

5. Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner

Key Features:

• Retractable twist-up mechanical pencil
• Self-sharpening tip
• Waterproof, transfer-proof, smudge-proof
• Creamy glide-on formula
• Long-lasting color in 5 shades

My Review: This pencil glides on like butter without any skipping or dragging. It sets quickly into a budge-proof liner that withstands water, humidity, tears, and sweat without fading or running. The built-in sharpener ensures you always have a precise tip for flawless application. While not quite as intensely pigmented as pricier options, the shades deliver decent color payoff.

Best For: Low-maintenance eyeliner that stays put through anything. The self-sharpening feature makes it ideal for on-the-go application.

Price: $6.48

6. Revlon Colorstay 2-In-1 Angled Kajal Eyeliner

Key Features:

• Double-ended liner with 2 applicator tips (fine & wide)
• Soft, blendable kajal formula
• Ophthalmologist tested, safe for sensitive eyes
• Smoky matte finish
• Intense color payoff

My Review: Revlon‘s 2-in-1 Angled Kajal liner lets you achieve soft smudgy looks on one end and bold crisp definition on the other. The creamy mineral-enriched formula glides on effortlessly. While not waterproof, it resists transferring and lasts all day without smudging on the waterline. The angled applicators provide excellent control for tightlining.

Best For: Smoky, sultry eye looks. The blendable texture also allows you to smudge for seamless smokey definition.

Price: $6.58 – $9.99

7. Milani Stay Put Matte Eyeliner

Key Features:

• Richly pigmented matte formula
• Extremely budge-proof, up to 17 hours wear
• Smooth application
• Built-in sharpener in base
• Available in black, brown, navy and emerald

My Review: This eyeliner goes on like liquid but locks down like a powder. The super-fine felt tip allows you to create thin, precise lines or thicker bold definition. Once set, this matte liner withstands smudging, running, and fading remarkably well. The sharpener ensures you always have a flawless point. While not waterproof, the transfer-resistance is top-notch.

Best For: Creating crisp, perfect cateyes and bold liner looks that require serious staying power. The fine tip offers ultimate control.

Price: $6.97

Eyeliner Shopping Tips for Walmart

• Look for “Rollbacks” where prices have recently been reduced. Walmart marks these in red.

• Check endcaps for deals on newly launched or seasonal products.

• Look up online first to read reviews before purchasing in-store.

• Download the Walmart app to scan products and compare prices as you shop.

• Join Walmart+ for free shipping with no order minimum and member prices.

• Sign up for emails to receive discounts and alerts on sales events.

Get the Most Out of Your Eyeliners

To make your new eyeliners last:

• Store upright at room temperature away from humidity.

• Twist pencils back down fully when not in use to avoid breaking the core.

• Keep liquid liner tips clean and never store them upside down.

• Sharpen pencils carefully using short strokes. Never sharpen to a stub.

• Clean brushes regularly with brush shampoo to avoid product buildup.

Troubleshooting Eyeliner Issues

Smudging: Use an eyeshadow primer before applying eyeliner. Set liner with translucent powder or finishing spray. Choose a waterproof pencil or liquid formula.

Fading: Opt for a long-wearing formula rated for 8+ hours. Refresh liner after a few hours if needed. Avoid oily makeup removers that can break down liner prematurely.

Uneven Application: Rest your arm on a steady surface for better control. Use small strokes and connect the dashes. Let gel/liquid liner set before fully opening eyes.

Irritation: Look for eyeliners labeled non-irritating, allergy-tested, fragrance-free. Stop using if irritation occurs and switch formulas.

The Takeaway: Get Stunning Eyes with the Best Eyeliners from Walmart

Whether you love subtle definition or bold graphic liner, Walmart has a top-rated eyeliner for you at an affordable price point. From user-friendly pencils to intense liquid liners, these products deliver striking eye looks that last.

Hopefully this guide gave you eyeliner inspiration and tips for choosing the perfect formula and applying it flawlessly. With practice and the right products, you can achieve next-level eye makeup with ease. So get ready to wow with your gorgeous gaze!